Ch4. Real Estate Agency Law and License Law — US License Exam

Agency and License Law: Exam Topic Analysis

National exam breakdown:

Agency relationships and duties:    ~20–25%
Listing and buyer agreements:       ~15%
Commission and compensation:        ~10%
Prohibited acts and misconduct:     ~15–20%
License law (state-specific):       ~20%
Real estate transaction procedures: ~10–15%

Real Estate Brokerage: License Requirements

License Requirements by Tier

License	Requirements
Salesperson	Pre-licensing education + exam + sponsoring broker
Broker	Salesperson experience (1–3 yrs) + additional education + exam
Broker-associate	Broker license but works under a managing broker

Dual license prohibition: A salesperson may only be associated with one sponsoring broker at a time.
Business restrictions: Licensees may not engage in activities that create conflicts of interest with real estate clients (state-specific rules vary).

Disqualification / Denial Grounds

Absolute bars to licensing (common across states):
① Lack of legal capacity (minor, adjudicated incompetent)
② Undischarged bankruptcy (in some states)
③ Felony convictions — especially fraud, forgery, theft, mortgage fraud
④ Prior license revocation within a lookback period (typically 3–5 years)
⑤ Making dual contracts (contract fraud)
⑥ Practicing while license is suspended

Agency Disclosure and Fiduciary Duties

Agency Relationships Defined

An agent is a person authorized to act on behalf of another (the principal) and whose acts bind the principal. In real estate:

Seller’s Agent: Represents the seller exclusively
Buyer’s Agent: Represents the buyer exclusively
Dual Agent: Represents both buyer and seller in the same transaction (requires written consent of both; restricted in some states)
Designated Agent: In a dual agency situation, the broker designates one agent to represent the buyer and another to represent the seller
Transaction Broker / Facilitator: A non-agency role in some states — assists both parties without fiduciary duties to either

Fiduciary Duties (COALD or OLD CAR)

Memorize: COALD
C — Confidentiality: Keep client information confidential
O — Obedience: Follow lawful client instructions
A — Accounting: Account for all money and property
L — Loyalty: Put client's interests ahead of own
D — Disclosure: Disclose all material facts affecting the client's decision

Plus reasonable care and skill (implied duty).

What agents must disclose to buyers regardless of agency:

Material defects known to the agent
Stigmatized property issues (depends on state law)
Environmental hazards (lead, asbestos, radon, mold)
Death on the property (varies by state)

What agents must NOT disclose:

Race, religion, or national origin of neighbors (Fair Housing Act)
Seller’s minimum acceptable price (if representing seller)
Buyer’s maximum willingness to pay (if representing buyer)

Listing Agreements

The listing agreement is a contract between the seller and the broker, authorizing the broker to find a buyer.

Types of Listing Agreements

Exclusive Right to Sell:
- Broker earns commission regardless of who finds the buyer
- Most common form used in residential transactions
- Provides maximum motivation for broker to market aggressively

Exclusive Agency:
- Broker earns commission if any agent (including cooperating agents) finds the buyer
- Seller reserves the right to sell personally without paying a commission
- Less common; creates confusion about commission if seller finds own buyer

Open Listing:
- Non-exclusive; seller may list with multiple brokers
- Commission paid only to the broker who produces the ready, willing, and able buyer
- No commission if seller sells on their own
- Rare for residential; sometimes used for commercial or land

Essential Elements of a Listing Agreement

Parties: Seller and broker (licensed)
Property description (legal description recommended)
Listing price
Commission or compensation terms
Listing period (expiration date)
Broker’s authority
MLS authorization (if applicable)
Seller’s signature

Listing agreement termination: By expiration, mutual agreement, sale of property, destruction of property, death or incapacity of seller or broker, or unilateral breach.

Buyer Representation Agreements

Post-NAR Settlement (2024): Buyer’s agents are now required to have a written buyer representation agreement in place before showing properties. Key terms:

Compensation terms clearly stated upfront
Duration and geographic scope
Buyer’s obligations to the agent
Dispute resolution

Commission structure (post-2024): The seller’s offer of compensation to buyer’s agent is no longer displayed in MLS. Buyers and their agents must negotiate and agree on compensation. Sellers may still voluntarily offer a buyer agent commission as a selling concession.

Prohibited Acts in Real Estate Practice

Absolute prohibitions:
① Direct purchase of client property by agent (self-dealing / undisclosed interest)
② Accepting fees or compensation beyond agreed-upon commission without client's written consent
③ False or misleading advertising (virtual staging misrepresentation, hidden fees)
④ Dual contracts (one contract for the lender, another showing a different price)
⑤ Encouraging violations of fair housing law (steering, blockbusting)
⑥ Commingling: mixing client funds (escrow) with agent's personal funds

Penalties for violations:

Dual contracts → License revocation + potential criminal prosecution (wire fraud, bank fraud)
False advertising → Fine up to $500–$ 11,000+ (FTC advertising rules)
Commingling → License suspension or revocation in all states

Real Estate Commission / Compensation

Commission Rates (Post-NAR Settlement)

There is no fixed commission rate — all commissions are negotiated. Industry context:

Pre-2024 typical:
5–6% of sale price, split 50/50 between listing broker and buyer's broker

Post-2024:
Rates remain negotiable but are explicitly uncoupled:
- Listing side compensation: negotiated in listing agreement
- Buyer side compensation: negotiated in buyer representation agreement
- No longer auto-shared through MLS

Commission Calculation Examples

Example 1: 
Sale price: $400,000; Listing agent rate: 2.5%
Commission = $400,000 × 2.5% = $10,000

Example 2:
Sale price: $800,000; Total commission: 5%
Split: 60/40 to listing/buyer side
Listing broker: $800,000 × 5% × 60% = $24,000
Buyer broker: $800,000 × 5% × 40% = $16,000

Commission always paid to the broker, not the salesperson directly. The broker then pays the salesperson their split per their employment agreement.

Real Estate Transaction Disclosure

Mandatory disclosure: Most states require a Property Condition Disclosure or Seller’s Disclosure — seller’s written disclosure of known material defects:

Roof condition, foundation, HVAC systems
Environmental hazards (lead, asbestos, mold, radon)
Presence of HOA and associated fees
Zoning variances, permits, code violations

Seller’s disclosure is NOT a substitute for buyer’s inspection. Agents should recommend professional inspections for all buyers.

License Law Administrative Enforcement

Typical disciplinary progression:
Informal complaint → Investigation → Formal charge → Hearing → Decision

Penalties available:
Reprimand / Warning → Fine → Probation → Suspension → Revocation

License revocation grounds:
- Dual contracts
- Fraud or misrepresentation
- Commingling of funds
- Felony conviction
- Gross negligence
- Practicing while suspended

After revocation: reinstatement eligibility varies by state (typically 3–5 year waiting period)

Practice Exam Questions

Q1. A seller tells her agent that she will accept $380,000 for her home, although it is listed at$ 415,000. The listing agent shows this property to her own buyer client. What must the agent do?

Disclose the dual agency situation and obtain written consent from both parties. In a single-agent arrangement, the seller’s minimum acceptable price is confidential and must not be shared with the buyer without the seller’s permission.

Q2. What is the maximum period a salesperson’s license may be suspended before it becomes a revocation in most states?

Typically 6–12 months (state-specific). Suspension is temporary; revocation permanently ends the license (subject to reinstatement petition).

Q3. What happens to the commission if a seller refuses to close after the listing broker produces a ready, willing, and able buyer at full price?

The broker has earned the commission upon producing a ready, willing, and able buyer who accepts the seller’s terms. The seller may owe the commission even if the seller refuses to close, depending on state law and the listing agreement terms.

Q4. What is commingling, and why is it prohibited?

Commingling is mixing client escrow funds with the broker’s personal or operating funds. It is prohibited because client funds could be lost if the broker becomes insolvent, and it makes it impossible to account accurately for client money. All states require dedicated trust accounts for earnest money and other client funds.

OIYO Editorial