Ch10. Real Estate Agent Duties and Ethics — License Law, Commission, and Professional Standards

Overview of Real Estate License Law

Real estate license law: State statutes governing who must hold a license to practice real estate and how they must conduct themselves.

Brokerage: The act of representing a buyer, seller, landlord, or tenant in a real estate transaction in exchange for compensation.

Agency Relationship:
Seller (Client) ─── Listing Agreement ───→ Listing Broker
Buyer (Client)  ─── Buyer Representation ─→ Buyer's Broker
                             ↓
                    Facilitate Transaction
                    (MLS, negotiation, contract)

Obtaining a Real Estate License

License Requirements (General — varies by state)

Complete pre-licensing education (45–180 hours depending on state)
Pass the state licensing exam (national + state portions)
Submit to a background check
Affiliate with a licensed broker (salesperson cannot practice independently)
Complete post-licensing education within first 1–2 years

License Hierarchy

Salesperson / Sales Agent: Works under a supervising broker; cannot practice independently.

Broker: Higher license; can operate independently, supervise agents, and hold client funds.

Broker-Associate: Holds a broker license but works under another broker.

Agency Relationships and Fiduciary Duties

Types of Agency

Seller’s agent (listing agent): Owes fiduciary duties exclusively to the seller
Buyer’s agent: Owes fiduciary duties exclusively to the buyer
Dual agent: Represents both buyer and seller in the same transaction — legal in most states with written informed consent from both parties; limited fiduciary duties
Transaction coordinator / facilitator: Assists both parties without representing either

The COLD AC Fiduciary Duties (to the client)

C — Care (reasonable competence)
O — Obedience (follow lawful instructions)
L — Loyalty (put client's interests first)
D — Disclosure (disclose all material facts)
A — Accounting (handle money responsibly)
C — Confidentiality (protect client's private information)

Agent Commission Structure

Commission: Compensation paid to the broker upon successful completion of a transaction. Always negotiable — there is no legally fixed rate.

Typical Structure

Transaction Type	Typical Range	Notes
Residential sale	5–6% of sale price	Split between listing and buyer’s broker
Commercial sale	3–6% (negotiated)	Often lower on larger deals
Residential lease	1 month’s rent or 5–8%	Varies widely by market

NAR settlement (2024): Buyers must now sign a written buyer representation agreement that specifies the buyer’s agent compensation before touring properties. Commission is no longer automatically offered in the MLS.

Commission Split

Total Commission (e.g., 5%)
  → Listing Broker: 2.5%
     → Listing Agent: 1.5–2.0% (after brokerage split)
  → Buyer's Broker: 2.5%
     → Buyer's Agent: 1.5–2.0% (after brokerage split)

Prohibited Acts

Common grounds for license disciplinary action:

Commingling: Mixing client funds with the agent’s personal funds — one of the most serious violations
Conversion: Using client funds for personal use — grounds for criminal prosecution
Misrepresentation / fraud: Stating false facts or concealing material information
Undisclosed dual agency: Acting for both parties without written consent
Kickbacks: Accepting undisclosed compensation from third parties (also a RESPA violation)
Blockbusting: Inducing sales by suggesting that protected-class persons are moving into the area
Steering: Directing clients toward or away from neighborhoods based on protected characteristics
Churning: Excessive transactions motivated by commission, not client interest

Disqualification Grounds

The following may result in license denial, suspension, or revocation:

Conviction of a crime involving moral turpitude or fraud
Misrepresentation on a license application
Commingling or conversion of client funds
Practicing without a license (or aiding unlicensed activity)
Violations of fair housing law

NAR Code of Ethics

Members of the National Association of REALTORS® (NAR) are bound by the Code of Ethics, which goes beyond state license law.

Key obligations:

Duty to put clients’ interests ahead of personal interests
Honest and truthful representation of property
Cooperation with other brokers
No discrimination based on any protected characteristic
Transparency about agency relationships

Ethics complaints: Filed with the local Board of REALTORS®; may result in fines, suspension from MLS, or membership termination.

Key Concept Cards

Fiduciary Duty — COLD AC ★★★★★ : Care, Obedience, Loyalty, Disclosure, Accounting, Confidentiality — the six duties owed to a client (principal) in an agency relationship. Memory tip: COLD AC — the six fiduciary duties

Commission is Always Negotiable ★★★★★ : No government body sets commission rates. The rate is determined by the listing agreement between broker and client. Price-fixing among brokers violates antitrust law. Memory tip: Negotiated, not fixed — antitrust applies

E&O Insurance Requirements ★★★★☆ : Errors and omissions insurance protects agents and brokers from negligence claims. Required by most states and brokerages. Typical coverage: $100,000–$ 1,000,000. Memory tip: E&O = professional liability insurance for agents

Practice Quiz

Q. A listing agent learns that the seller’s home has foundation issues but the seller instructs the agent not to disclose them. What should the agent do?

The agent owes the seller loyalty and obedience — but only for lawful instructions. Concealing known material defects is a breach of the agent’s disclosure duty to buyers, a violation of state license law, and potentially fraudulent misrepresentation. The agent must either disclose or withdraw from the listing.

Q. In a dual agency, what limitations apply to the agent’s fiduciary duties?

In dual agency the agent cannot give undivided loyalty to either party. The agent cannot disclose the buyer’s highest price to the seller, or the seller’s lowest acceptable price to the buyer. Confidential information must be protected for both parties. For this reason, dual agency requires fully informed written consent from both the buyer and seller before the agency relationship is created.

Real Estate Basics — Series Review

Ch1  Introduction            — Characteristics of land, market structure, cycles
Ch2  Value Theory            — Rent theories, appraisal principles, three approaches
Ch3  Investment Analysis     — NOI, returns, leverage, LTV, DTI, DSCR
Ch4  Zoning & Land Use       — Zoning districts, lot coverage, FAR, permits
Ch5  Contracts & Transactions — Purchase agreements, landlord-tenant law, title
Ch6  Real Estate Finance     — Mortgages, interest types, amortization, REITs
Ch7  Housing Policy          — Section 8, LIHTC, rent control, fair housing
Ch8  Commercial RE           — Office, retail, industrial, cap rates, DSCR
Ch9  Taxation                — Transfer tax, property tax, capital gains, 1031
Ch10 Agent Duties & Ethics   — License law, fiduciary duty, commission, NAR ethics

OIYO Editorial