
Financial Management — Practical Cost of Capital and Divisional WACC
A company-wide WACC can reject worthwhile lower-risk investments
Chapter 4 covers CAPM and the cost of equity; Chapter 6 covers weighting equity and after-tax debt costs. Here we examine when those inputs do not match a project’s risk.
1. A regression beta of 1.2 is an estimate from one sample
Assume a hypothetical risk-free rate of 3% and market risk premium of 5%. A beta of 1.2 estimated from five years of weekly returns gives . With market-value debt weight , pretax debt cost , and tax rate , the company WACC is 7.2%. The tax rate is an example input, not a statement of current Korean tax law.
If a two-year daily-return estimate instead gives beta 0.9, the same inputs imply and WACC 6.3%. This is a hypothetical sensitivity comparison, not an observed result. Beta measures sensitivity to market returns, not total stock-price volatility.
For a given business risk, debt leverage changes equity risk. Remove the capital-structure effect from comparable firms’ equity betas, then adjust for the division’s target leverage. Check whether treating debt beta as zero is appropriate. One raw regression estimate is not a definitive cost of capital.
2. A 7.2% company rate can reject a lower-risk positive-NPV project
Suppose a lower-risk division has beta 0.7 and no debt. Its discount rate is . A hypothetical project costs 100 today and pays 107 in one year, giving IRR 7.0%. At the risk-appropriate rate, NPV is . At the company’s 7.2%, it is , so the same project is rejected. All cash amounts use the same arbitrary unit.
This example has one initial outflow followed by a positive inflow. Do not rank mutually exclusive projects or cash flows with multiple sign changes solely by IRR. Match free cash flow to the firm (FCFF) with a risk- and financing-appropriate WACC, and free cash flow to equity (FCFE) with equity cost. Match currency and nominal versus real assumptions too.
| Case | Appropriate rate | Misapplication |
|---|---|---|
| Company-average risk and target financing | Company WACC 7.2% | Use only when risk and financing match |
| Unlevered lower-risk division | Divisional rate 6.5% | Using 7.2% rejects the example's positive NPV |
| Business risk above the company average | Rate matched to that business | A company rate that is too low may accept a negative-NPV project |
The lower-risk division is unlevered to make the financing assumption explicit. With debt, do not simply call 6.5% its WACC: recalculate leverage-adjusted equity cost and after-tax debt cost.
Check your understanding
Problem. Calculate the company’s WACC and value the unlevered lower-risk project costing 100 and paying 107 in one year at both 6.5% and the company rate. Is the difference between IRR and the discount rate an NPV amount?
Solution. . Divisional NPV is about +0.47; company-rate NPV is about −0.19. The 7.0% IRR is 0.5 percentage points above the divisional rate and 0.2 points below the company rate. These rate differences are not cash amounts. Correct arithmetic cannot rescue a discount rate mismatched to risk.
References
- Richard Brealey, Stewart Myers, and Franklin Allen, Principles of Corporate Finance, ch. 9, 19
- Stephen Ross, Randolph Westerfield, and Jeffrey Jaffe, Corporate Finance, ch. 12–13
- Eugene Brigham and Joel Houston, Fundamentals of Financial Management, ch. 10
- Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern, Capital Structure — cost of capital and cash-flow matching
- Aswath Damodaran, Chapter 8 worked solutions — market weights and unlevering beta
- Aswath Damodaran, Chapter 5 worked solutions — IRR and NPV rankings
Oiyo
Editorial DeskThe OIYO editorial desk researches money, law, lifestyle, and self-understanding topics against primary sources and public statistics. Every piece carries source notes and is reviewed on a regular cycle for accuracy and usefulness.