Accounting•Chapter 7•6 min read•Updated September 24, 2026

Auditing — The Audit Opinion and Report: Modified Opinions and Key Audit Matters

O
OiyoContributor
7/8
Auditing — The Audit Opinion and Report: Modified Opinions and Key Audit Matters

An audit’s conclusion is summed up in one line: the opinion in the auditor’s report. To reach it, the auditor accumulates and evaluates the misstatements found and judges whether sufficient evidence has been obtained. This chapter covers the types of opinion, how to choose among them and how the auditor’s report is structured. Materiality was set in chapter 2.

1. Evaluating uncorrected misstatements

All misstatements found during the audit above the clearly trivial threshold are accumulated (KSA 450). Management is asked to correct them, and the total of uncorrected misstatements is compared with materiality.

Judging uncorrected misstatements
∑Uncorrected misstatements (factual + judgemental + projected)  vs  Overall materiality\sum \text{Uncorrected misstatements (factual + judgemental + projected)} \;\text{vs}\; \text{Overall materiality}
Factual misstatements are those where the facts are clear, judgemental misstatements are differences between management's and the auditor's estimates, and projected misstatements are those extrapolated from a sample to the population.

AM’s overall materiality is ₩100 million. At the end of the audit, a cut-off error of ₩40 million (factual), a difference in the estimate of the loss allowance of ₩35 million (judgemental) and a misstatement of ₩30 million projected from an inventory sample (projected) remain. The total of ₩105 million exceeds materiality. If management corrects only the cut-off error, the remaining ₩65 million is below materiality and an unmodified opinion can be issued. Projected misstatements carry sampling risk, however, so the judgement should leave a margin.

2. Types of audit opinion

Choosing a modified opinion
CauseMaterial but not pervasiveMaterial and pervasive
Material misstatement of the financial statementsQualified opinionAdverse opinion
Inability to obtain sufficient appropriate evidence (scope limitation)Qualified opinionDisclaimer of opinion
  • Unmodified opinion: the financial statements are presented fairly, in all material respects.
  • Qualified opinion: fair except for a specific matter; the effect is material but does not pervade the financial statements.
  • Adverse opinion: misstatements are so pervasive that they affect the financial statements as a whole.
  • Disclaimer of opinion: the auditor cannot express an opinion for lack of evidence, and the possible effects could be pervasive.

Pervasive effects are those not confined to specific items, or, if confined, representing a substantial part of the financial statements, or, for disclosures, fundamental to users’ understanding. For example, if attendance at a subsidiary’s inventory count is impossible, first consider whether an alternative count date and testing intervening transactions or other procedures provide sufficient evidence. If evidence remains insufficient, possible undetected misstatements that are material but not pervasive lead to a qualified opinion; possible material and pervasive effects lead to a disclaimer. An inventory balance of 3% of assets does not by itself determine the opinion.

A listed company receiving a non-clean opinion (qualified, adverse or disclaimer) may be designated as an administrative issue or face delisting, so the consequences are serious.

3. Structure of the auditor’s report

An auditor’s report under KSA 700 puts the Opinion section first, followed by the Basis for Opinion, (where applicable) a material uncertainty related to going concern, Key Audit Matters, other matter, the responsibilities of management and those charged with governance for the financial statements, and the auditor’s responsibilities.

A. Key audit matters (KAM)

These describe, in the auditor’s professional judgement, the matters of most significance in the audit of the current period (KSA 701): why each is a key audit matter and how it was addressed in the audit. Korea phased them in for listed companies, and they now appear in the reports of all listed companies. Revenue recognition, goodwill impairment, capitalization of development costs and inventory valuation are common topics. Key audit matters do not modify the opinion.

B. Emphasis of matter and other matter

  • Emphasis of matter: draws attention to a matter already appropriately disclosed in the financial statements that is fundamental to users’ understanding (uncertainty over a major lawsuit, a major catastrophe and so on).
  • Other matter: refers to a matter not disclosed in the financial statements that is relevant to understanding the audit or the auditor’s responsibilities (such as the prior-period statements having been audited by another auditor).

An emphasis of matter does not modify the opinion either. A going-concern uncertainty is reported in a separate “Material Uncertainty Related to Going Concern” section (chapter 8).

Check your understanding

AN’s overall materiality is ₩500 million and its total assets ₩100 billion. The auditor (1) could not obtain sufficient evidence on a ₩3 billion investment in an overseas subsidiary because the local auditor’s information was not provided, and (2) found that management had not recognized lease liabilities of ₩8 billion and right-of-use assets of ₩8 billion. Management refused to correct (2). What opinion should be issued?

(1) concerns insufficient evidence. ₩3 billion exceeds materiality of ₩500 million, but 3% of assets does not establish that possible effects are non-pervasive. It would independently justify qualification only on the additional assumptions that alternative procedures cannot provide sufficient evidence and possible effects are material but not pervasive. (2) is a misstatement. ₩8 billion is 16 times materiality and affects the debt ratio and several notes, so the extent of its effect on users’ judgements must be weighed. If the effect is judged confined to specific items in the statement of financial position, the opinion is qualified; if it is judged pervasive, distorting the whole debt structure, the opinion is adverse. When both causes are present, the opinion is based on the more serious one and both are described in the basis section.

References

  • Korean Institute of CPAs, Korean Standards on Auditing, KSA 700 Forming an Opinion and Reporting on Financial Statements and KSA 701 Communicating Key Audit Matters in the Independent Auditor’s Report
  • Korean Institute of CPAs, Korean Standards on Auditing, KSA 705 Modifications to the Opinion, KSA 706 Emphasis of Matter Paragraphs and Other Matter Paragraphs and KSA 450 Evaluation of Misstatements Identified during the Audit
  • Alvin Arens, Randal Elder and Mark Beasley, Auditing and Assurance Services, ch. 3
O

Oiyo

Editorial Desk

The OIYO editorial desk researches money, law, lifestyle, and self-understanding topics against primary sources and public statistics. Every piece carries source notes and is reviewed on a regular cycle for accuracy and usefulness.