
Intermediate Accounting — Provisions and Contingent Liabilities: Recognition, Best Estimate and Present Value
A provision is a liability of uncertain timing or amount. Unlike ordinary liabilities it involves estimation, so the heart of the standard is when to recognize it as a liability and at what amount. The standard is K-IFRS 1037 Provisions, Contingent Liabilities and Contingent Assets (IAS 37). Financial liabilities such as bonds were covered in chapter 7.
1. Recognition criteria
A provision is recognized when all three of the following are met.
- The entity has a present obligation (legal or constructive) as a result of a past event.
- It is probable (more likely than not) that an outflow of resources embodying economic benefits will be required to settle the obligation.
- A reliable estimate can be made of the amount.
A constructive obligation arises when past practice or published policies create a valid expectation in others that the entity will discharge the responsibility. Even without a legal obligation, consistently honouring a policy of “free refunds within one year of purchase” creates a constructive obligation.
A. It must not depend on future actions
A present obligation must be one the entity cannot avoid whatever it does in future. An obligation to clean up pollution a factory has already caused is a present obligation. But if a change in the law requires filters to be fitted to the factory within three years, the entity can avoid this by closing the factory or changing how it operates, so there is no present obligation. Future operating losses are not provisions either.
2. Contingent liabilities and contingent assets
| Situation | Treatment |
|---|---|
| Present obligation, outflow probable, reliable estimate possible | Recognize a provision |
| Present obligation, outflow probable, no estimate possible (extremely rare) | Disclose as a contingent liability |
| Present obligation uncertain, or outflow not probable | Disclose as a contingent liability |
| Outflow remote | No disclosure |
| Contingent asset with probable inflow of benefits | Disclose in the notes (not recognized) |
| Inflow of benefits virtually certain | Not a contingent asset; recognize as an asset |
Contingent assets are not recognized so as not to bring forward unrealized gains. This is a typical area where liabilities and assets are treated asymmetrically.
3. Measurement: the best estimate
A provision is measured at the best estimate of the expenditure required to settle the obligation at the end of the reporting period.
A. A large population: expected value
Company X sold 1,000 appliances this year. Experience shows that 20% have minor defects costing ₩50,000 each to repair, 5% have major defects costing ₩400,000 each, and the remaining 75% have none.
B. A single obligation: the most likely outcome
For a single obligation, such as one lawsuit, the most likely outcome is the starting point. But if the other possible outcomes are mostly higher or lower, the estimate is adjusted in that direction.
C. Present value and interest expense
Where the time value of money is material, the provision is measured at present value. At the beginning of 20X1, company Y took on an obligation to dismantle and restore equipment in three years’ time; the estimated cost is ₩10 million and the discount rate 5%. The initial provision is (₩10,000), i.e. about ₩8.638 million, and the same amount is added to the cost of the equipment. Each year the opening provision multiplied by the discount rate is recognized as interest expense: ₩432,000 in 20X1, ₩453,000 in 20X2 and ₩476,000 in 20X3, so that the provision reaches ₩10 million at the end of year 3.
4. Special cases
- Onerous contracts: recognize the unavoidable net loss from the present contractual obligation as a provision. Compare the net cost of fulfilment, including its expected benefits, with compensation or penalties for exit; do not provide for the gross fulfilment cost. Fulfilment costs include incremental costs and allocations of other directly related costs (amendment effective from 2022). Recognize impairment of assets used in fulfilling the contract before establishing the separate provision.
- Restructuring: a constructive obligation arises when there is a detailed formal plan and the entity has started to implement it or announced its main features to those affected, raising a valid expectation. A board decision alone is not enough. Retraining or relocating continuing staff and investment in new systems are not included.
- Reimbursements: amounts to be reimbursed by third parties, such as insurance, are recognized as a separate asset only when virtually certain and are not offset against the provision.
| Choice | Remaining amount (unit: ₩10,000) |
|---|---|
| Fulfil | Cost 130 − expected benefits 100 = net loss 30 |
| Exit | Penalty 40; no further benefits or costs after exit |
| Provision | Unavoidable net loss 30 |
This example assumes no additional asset impairment and no material time-value effect. If only the exit penalty falls to 20, the unavoidable net loss is 20. Do not add costs already incurred to the remaining fulfilment costs or count an impairment loss again in the provision.
Check your understanding
At the end of 20X1 company Z faces two lawsuits. In lawsuit A, the probability of losing is 70%, and if it loses, damages will be ₩5 million (60%) or ₩8 million (40%). In lawsuit B, the probability of losing is 30%, with damages of ₩10 million if it loses. It is also virtually certain that an insurer will reimburse half of the damages in lawsuit A. How is this reflected in the financial statements?
For lawsuit A an outflow is probable, so a provision is recognized. As a single obligation, the most likely outcome of ₩5 million is the starting point. But the other outcome (₩8 million, 40%) is higher, so the standard requires an amount above ₩5 million as the best estimate; the probability-weighted amount (₩10,000), i.e. ₩6.2 million, is a reference for that judgement. The insurance reimbursement is virtually certain and is recognized as a separate asset, not offset against the provision; in the income statement the provision expense may be presented net of the reimbursement. For lawsuit B an outflow is not probable, so nothing is recognized and it is disclosed as a contingent liability.
References
- Korea Accounting Standards Board, K-IFRS 1037 Provisions, Contingent Liabilities and Contingent Assets (including the 2022 amendment on onerous contracts)
- Korea Accounting Standards Board, K-IFRS Interpretation 2101 Changes in Existing Decommissioning, Restoration and Similar Liabilities
- Donald Kieso, Jerry Weygandt and Terry Warfield, Intermediate Accounting: IFRS Edition, ch. 13
Oiyo
Editorial DeskThe OIYO editorial desk researches money, law, lifestyle, and self-understanding topics against primary sources and public statistics. Every piece carries source notes and is reviewed on a regular cycle for accuracy and usefulness.