
Managerial Accounting — Decisions and Relevant Costs: Sunk Costs, Opportunity Costs and Incremental Analysis
Managerial accounting is the accounting information managers use to plan, decide and control. The course runs through decisions (chapters 1–3), planning and budgets (chapter 4), performance evaluation (chapters 5–6), long-term investment (chapter 7) and strategic cost management (chapter 8). How costs are calculated was covered in Cost Accounting. This first chapter sets out relevant costs, the starting point of every decision analysis.
1. Managerial and financial accounting
| Criterion | Financial accounting | Managerial accounting |
|---|---|---|
| Users | External: shareholders, creditors | Internal: managers |
| Regulation | Accounting standards such as K-IFRS | Unregulated; usefulness is the test |
| Time frame | Past performance | Forecasts and plans |
| Unit | Whole company | Products, departments, customers, projects |
| Precision | Emphasis on verifiability | Emphasis on timeliness and relevance |
2. The two conditions for relevance
A cost is relevant to a decision only if it meets both conditions.
- It occurs in the future. Money already spent cannot be recovered whatever you choose.
- It differs between alternatives. An amount that is the same whichever alternative is chosen does not affect the comparison.
| Concept | Definition | Relevance |
|---|---|---|
| Sunk cost | Cost already incurred that cannot be recovered (such as the carrying amount of existing equipment) | Irrelevant |
| Opportunity cost | The greatest benefit that would have been earned from the alternative not chosen | Relevant (even though no cash changes hands) |
| Avoidable cost | Cost that can be eliminated by choosing an alternative | Relevant |
| Unavoidable cost | Cost that continues whichever alternative is chosen | Irrelevant |
| Incremental (differential) cost | The difference in cost between two alternatives | Relevant |
3. An equipment replacement decision
Company BI is weighing whether to keep a machine bought four years ago or replace it with a new one. Ignore the time value of money (long-term investment is covered in chapter 7).
| Item | Existing machine | New machine |
|---|---|---|
| Carrying amount | 400 | — |
| Proceeds if sold now | 100 | — |
| Cost | — | 900 |
| Remaining useful life | 4 years | 4 years |
| Annual operating costs | 300 | 150 |
| Disposal value in 4 years | 0 | 0 |
The existing machine’s ₩4 million carrying amount is a sunk cost and enters neither side. Replacing it would record a ₩3 million loss on disposal, but that loss merely reveals a cost paid four years ago; keeping the machine turns the same ₩4 million into depreciation expense over time. By contrast, the ₩1 million receivable if sold now is given up by keeping the machine, so it is relevant.
4. Incremental analysis and qualitative factors
Gathering only the relevant items to see the difference between two alternatives is incremental analysis. For the decision above:
- Incremental cost of replacing: new machine ₩9 million
- Incremental benefits of replacing: disposal proceeds ₩1 million, operating cost savings of (₩6 million)
- Net effect: (−₩2 million)
Look at factors beyond the numbers too. If the new machine improves quality and reduces returns, or the old machine carries a high risk of breakdown, the conclusion could change. Relevant cost analysis sets out precisely what can be expressed in numbers and so provides a baseline for such judgements.
Check your understanding
Company BJ wants to dispose of 1,000 obsolete parts left in inventory (carrying amount ₩20,000 each) in one of two ways. Sold as scrap, they fetch ₩3,000 each. Modified at a cost of ₩5,000 each, they can be sold for ₩10,000 each. Which is better, and how is the ₩20 million carrying amount treated?
The ₩20 million carrying amount is a sunk cost and irrelevant to both alternatives. Selling as scrap brings a net inflow of = ₩3 million; modifying and selling brings = ₩5 million. Modifying is ₩2 million better. Both show a loss in the books, but modifying is the one that reduces it.
References
- Charles Horngren, Srikant Datar and Madhav Rajan, Cost Accounting: A Managerial Emphasis, ch. 11
- Ray Garrison, Eric Noreen and Peter Brewer, Managerial Accounting, ch. 12
- Robert Kaplan and Anthony Atkinson, Advanced Management Accounting, ch. 1
Oiyo
Editorial DeskThe OIYO editorial desk researches money, law, lifestyle, and self-understanding topics against primary sources and public statistics. Every piece carries source notes and is reviewed on a regular cycle for accuracy and usefulness.