
Microeconomics — Scarcity, Opportunity Cost and the Production Possibilities Frontier
Microeconomics — Choice Starts with the Technology Constraint, Before Any Price Appears
If Introduction to Economics, Chapter 1 pinned down the definition of opportunity cost, this chapter writes that cost as a slope on the production technology. Every optimisation problem in microeconomics starts by writing down, in quantities, “what do I give up?” The consumer-side counterpart of this slope (the marginal rate of substitution) returns in Chapter 4, and the efficiency condition where the two meet returns in Chapter 10.
1. Opportunity cost counts costs that never appear in the books
The opportunity cost of a choice is the value of the next-best alternative given up. It includes not only explicit costs, which are paid in money, but also implicit costs: income forgone even though no money changes hands.
Suppose an employee quits a job paying KRW 35 million a year to spend one year in a graduate programme with KRW 10 million tuition.
- Explicit cost: tuition, KRW 10 million
- Implicit cost: forgone salary, KRW 35 million
- Total opportunity cost: KRW 45 million
Living expenses are left out. You eat and sleep whether you study or keep working, so they are not an additional cost created by this choice. Opportunity cost is the difference between “what you spend if you choose it” and “what you would spend anyway”.
2. The slope of the PPF is the marginal opportunity cost
Suppose an economy uses its resources and technology to produce only chips and wheat. The line joining the maximum combinations it can produce when all resources are used efficiently is the production possibilities frontier (PPF).
| Point | Chips | Wheat | Wheat given up per 2 extra chips |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | 20 | — | |
| A | 2 | 18 | 2 |
| B | 4 | 14 | 4 |
| 6 | 9.5 | 4.5 | |
| C | 8 | 4 | 5.5 |
Moving from A to B gains 2 chips and gives up 4 units of wheat, so one chip costs 2 units of wheat. Moving from B to C gains 4 chips for 10 units of wheat, so the opportunity cost of a chip rises to 2.5 units of wheat. The fact that each additional chip costs more wheat is called increasing opportunity cost.
Why is the MRT a ratio of marginal costs? Let one unit of resources be worth . One chip needs units of resources. Used for wheat, those resources produce units of wheat, because each unit of wheat needs units.
Points on the curve (A, B, C) are technically efficient, the point inside (D) leaves resources idle, and the point outside (E) cannot be reached with current resources and technology.
Why is it concave? Because resources are not equally useful for both goods. When we make only a few chips we move the resources best suited to chips first (skilled engineers, clean rooms). As we make more chips we must also move resources better suited to wheat (farmland, farm labour), so each extra chip costs more wheat. If every resource were equally useful for both goods, the PPF would be a straight line and the MRT constant.
A. Deriving the curve from production functions
The numbers in the table were assumptions. Let us see where the bowed shape comes from. Split 100 units of labour between chips and wheat, with technologies and . Both show diminishing marginal product. The labour required is and , and since :
We can check directly that this MRT equals the ratio of marginal costs. One more chip needs units of labour and one more unit of wheat , so — exactly the expression above. Conversely, if both technologies have constant returns (, ), the PPF is the straight line and the MRT is constant at 2. The bowed shape comes from diminishing marginal product (or specialised resources).
Given prices, where on the curve does the economy produce? Maximising the value of output along the curve puts production where an iso-revenue line touches the PPF, so . If chips cost twice as much as wheat, , i.e. ; substituting into the constraint gives , so and .
On X²+Y²/4=100, the point E(7.07, 14.14) where an iso-revenue line of slope −2 touches the curve maximises the value of output. As chips become relatively dearer, E slides down and to the right.
3. Being on the curve does not make a point optimal
A point on the PPF is technically efficient: no resources are left idle. Whether that combination is what people want is a separate question. Allocative efficiency is reached when the rate at which production can trade the goods (the MRT) equals the rate at which consumers are willing to trade them (the marginal rate of substitution, MRS).
If everyone wants much more wheat but the economy produces at C (8 chips, 4 wheat), production is technically efficient but allocatively inefficient. “On the PPF = optimal” is a false statement.
4. Why the curve shifts
- More resources (labour and capital accumulation): both intercepts move outward.
- Technical progress in one good: only that good’s intercept moves. If chip technology doubles, the chip intercept moves from 9 to 18 while the wheat intercept stays at 20. Because chips now need fewer resources, the freed resources can go to wheat, so at most combinations the economy can also have more wheat.
5. Sunk costs are not opportunity costs
A cost already paid that cannot be recovered is not an opportunity cost, because nothing is given up by future choices. Suppose KRW 30 million has been spent on unrecoverable equipment, and a further KRW 8 million would let the project recover KRW 12 million. The question is “do I get KRW 12 million by spending another KRW 8 million?” The net benefit is +KRW 4 million, so the project should continue. Adding the KRW 30 million already spent — “we spend KRW 38 million to recover 12” — leads to the wrong decision to stop. The opposite tendency, continuing a losing project because of sunk costs, is covered in Behavioural Economics, Chapter 6.
| Introductory course | Microeconomics, Chapter 1 |
|---|---|
| Opportunity cost = best alternative given up | Explicit + implicit cost; the MRT differs from point to point |
| Inside / on / outside the PPF | Technical efficiency ≠ allocative efficiency (MRT = MRS) |
| Ignore sunk costs | Only recoverable amounts are forward-looking costs |
If two countries have different MRTs, each can specialise in the good with the lower opportunity cost and trade, so that both consume combinations outside their own PPFs. This is comparative advantage; the calculations are in International Trade.
Check your understanding
Problem 1. On a straight-line PPF the economy can make at most 10 chips or 20 units of wheat. If it makes 6 chips, what is the most wheat it can make? What does it mean if the economy is producing (6 chips, 6 wheat)?
Solution. The opportunity cost of a chip is constant at units of wheat, so the maximum is . The point (6, 6) lies inside the curve. The opportunity cost has not changed; resources that could make 2 more units of wheat are sitting idle.
Problem 2. In the model above (), where does production move if chips and wheat come to have the same price?
Solution. , so , i.e. . Substituting gives , so and . When the relative price of chips falls from 2 to 1, chip output drops from 7.07 to 4.47. Because the PPF is bowed out, a change in relative prices shifts the output mix smoothly. With a straight-line PPF the economy would specialise completely at one end depending on whether the price ratio is above or below 2.
References
- Hal Varian, Intermediate Microeconomics, ch. 32
- N. Gregory Mankiw, Principles of Economics, ch. 1–3
- MIT OpenCourseWare, 14.01 Principles of Microeconomics
Oiyo
Editorial DeskThe OIYO editorial desk researches money, law, lifestyle, and self-understanding topics against primary sources and public statistics. Every piece carries source notes and is reviewed on a regular cycle for accuracy and usefulness.