
Microeconomics — Producer Theory: Cost Minimisation and Profit
Microeconomics — Profit Is Decided at the Margin, Not on Average
If Introduction to Economics, Chapter 4 wrote down MR = MC, this chapter works through the two steps behind it. First, find the cheapest combination of inputs for a given output (cost minimisation); then choose output using that cost (profit maximisation). This is also where we see why a firm shuts down in the short run when , not when .
1. Production functions and isoquants
The production function gives the maximum output from capital and labour . The marginal product is the extra output from one more unit of labour, holding other inputs fixed; it usually diminishes.
An isoquant joins input combinations that yield the same output. The absolute value of its slope is the marginal rate of technical substitution (MRTS) — how much capital one unit of labour can replace — and equals . It is the producer’s counterpart of the indifference curve and MRS in Chapter 4.
2. Cost minimisation
The condition for producing output as cheaply as possible, with wage and rental rate of capital , has the same structure as the consumer’s optimum.
With , won and won, , so . To produce 100 units we need , and gives and . The cost is (in units of 10,000 won), i.e. 4 million won.
When wages rise, firms substitute capital for labour to produce the same output (the substitution effect). If higher costs also cut output, labour demand falls further (the output effect). This is why both effects matter when discussing the employment impact of a minimum wage.
3. Short-run cost curves
In the short run capital is fixed, which creates fixed costs. Take total cost (in units of 10,000 won).
| Concept | Formula | At Q = 10 |
|---|---|---|
| Fixed cost FC | 200 | 2 million won |
| Variable cost VC | 40Q + Q² | 5 million won |
| Marginal cost MC | dTC/dQ = 40 + 2Q | 600,000 won |
| Average variable cost AVC | VC/Q = 40 + Q | 500,000 won |
| Average total cost ATC | TC/Q = 200/Q + 40 + Q | 700,000 won |
MC passes through the minimum of ATC. When MC is below the average it pulls the average down; when it is above, it pulls it up.
Marginal and average. If your exam average is 70 and your next score is 60, the average falls; if it is 80, the average rises. Costs work the same way. Where MC < ATC, ATC falls; where MC > ATC, it rises. So MC crosses ATC at its minimum. In the example, solving gives , where ATC is about 683,000 won.
4. The competitive firm’s short-run decision
A price-taker has , so it produces where . It then decides whether to produce at all. Fixed costs of 2 million won are paid even if the firm shuts, so the question is “do I cover variable costs?”
- won: gives . AVC is 600,000 won and ATC 700,000 won. Profit is 100,000 won per unit, 2 million won in total.
- won: . AVC is 425,000 won < 450,000 won, so the firm produces. Price is below ATC, so it makes a loss, but by producing it earns 62,500 won above variable cost, which covers part of the fixed cost.
- won: at every (minimum 400,000 won), so the firm shuts down. Its loss is limited to the fixed cost of 2 million won.
| Price | Output | Profit |
|---|---|---|
| P > minimum ATC | P = MC | Positive economic profit |
| Minimum AVC < P < minimum ATC | P = MC | Loss, but part of fixed cost recovered |
| P < minimum AVC | Q = 0 | Loss equal to fixed cost |
So the competitive firm’s short-run supply curve is the MC curve above the minimum of AVC. Chapter 6 adds these up into industry supply.
5. The long run and returns to scale
In the long run all inputs are variable, so there are no fixed costs. If multiplying all inputs by raises output by more than times, there are increasing returns to scale; exactly times, constant returns; less, decreasing returns. For these correspond to , and .
With increasing returns, long-run average cost falls (economies of scale). If it keeps falling over the whole range of market demand, supply by a single firm is cheapest. This is the natural monopoly of Chapter 7.
A. Deriving the cost function directly
Let us lift the calculation of section 2 to a general formula in output and factor prices . Substituting the cost-minimising condition into gives the conditional factor demands and the cost function.
For the general form , . Long-run average cost therefore falls if (increasing returns), is constant if , and rises if . Returns to scale are a property of the production function, and they carry over into the shape of the cost curve.
B. Short-run cost lies above long-run cost
Fix capital at . Producing then needs units of labour, so short-run total cost is . At , , equal to long-run cost; but at , , which is 50 more than the long-run cost of . Capital cannot be changed, so output can only be raised with ever more expensive labour.
With constant returns, long-run average cost is flat at 4. A plant with capital 25 touches it only at Q=50 (a), one with capital 50 only at Q=100 (b); elsewhere each is more expensive.
Check your understanding
Problem 1. A competitive firm has (in ten-thousand won) and faces . Find its optimal output and profit.
Solution. gives . ATC is , so profit per unit is about 26.7 and total profit is . The rule is , not .
Problem 2. With , and , find the minimum cost and factor mix for an output of 50. If capital is held at that level while output rises to 80, how much more does short-run cost exceed long-run cost?
Solution. , with and . Holding capital at 100 and producing needs , so . In the long run it would cost , so the short run costs 36 more. That is why costs climb steeply when output is raised in a hurry.
References
- Hal Varian, Intermediate Microeconomics, ch. 19–23
- N. Gregory Mankiw, Principles of Economics, ch. 13
- MIT OpenCourseWare, 14.01 Principles of Microeconomics
Oiyo
Editorial DeskThe OIYO editorial desk researches money, law, lifestyle, and self-understanding topics against primary sources and public statistics. Every piece carries source notes and is reviewed on a regular cycle for accuracy and usefulness.