
Microeconomics — Supply, Demand and Comparative Statics
Microeconomics — An Observed Price and Quantity Is an Intersection, Not a Demand Curve
If Introduction to Economics, Chapter 2 separated a shift of a curve from a movement along it, this chapter turns that distinction into a problem of identification. The prices and quantities recorded in data are points on neither the demand curve nor the supply curve; they are where the two met. We need to know which curve moved before we can interpret those points.
1. Solving the equilibrium in general form
Linear demand and supply () meet at:
With demand and supply , won and .
- If higher income moves demand to , then won and . Price and quantity rise together. By the formula, rose by 12, so price rises by and quantity by .
- If higher input costs move supply to , then won and . Price rises and quantity falls.
When demand shifts right, price and quantity rise together along the supply curve. Had supply shifted, price and quantity would have moved in opposite directions along the demand curve.
| Shock | Price | Quantity |
|---|---|---|
| Demand increases | ↑ | ↑ |
| Demand decreases | ↓ | ↓ |
| Supply increases | ↓ | ↑ |
| Supply decreases | ↑ | ↓ |
| Demand and supply both increase | Ambiguous | ↑ |
A. Beyond straight lines the signs stay the same — implicit differentiation
The formula above comes from straight lines, but the conclusion is general. Write demand with a shift variable such as income, , and supply as (, , ). Totally differentiating the equilibrium condition with respect to gives:
Multiplying by turns this into elasticities, a more useful form. When a shock pushes the demand curve out horizontally by percent:
In the section 1 example, the elasticities at are and . Pushing demand out by 12 units, i.e. , raises price by (30 → 34) and quantity by (40 → 44) — exactly what we solved directly. The less elastic supply is, the more a demand shock leaks into price rather than quantity. Tax incidence in chapter 3 is another face of this formula.
B. Does the market return to equilibrium? — Walrasian stability
Finding the intersection is one thing; the market moving to it is another. Suppose price rises when there is excess demand, with . Linearising around equilibrium gives , so if price returns to exponentially.
Stability is also why the signs of comparative statics can be trusted (Samuelson’s correspondence principle). If the equilibrium is unstable, the prediction “higher demand raises price” does not guarantee a path to the new equilibrium.
Price alone does not reveal the cause. If quantity rose with price, a demand shock dominated; if quantity fell, a supply shock dominated. When both curves move at once, the sign of one variable depends on their relative sizes and becomes ambiguous.
2. Why you cannot draw a demand curve by joining the dots
Suppose you plot a product’s yearly prices and sales and the points slope upward. It is tempting to conclude that “people buy more when the price is higher”, but if supply stayed put while demand grew every year, the points trace out the supply curve. To estimate a demand curve you need variation that moves supply while leaving demand unchanged (for example, weather shifting the supply of a crop). This is the identification problem of econometrics; its standard tool, instrumental variables, is covered in Econometrics, Chapter 4.
“Housing demand fell because interest rates rose” describes an event that shifted the demand curve through the cost of borrowing. “Transactions fell because house prices rose” may be a movement along the same demand curve, or the result of reduced supply. Misreading the cause leads to the opposite policy.
3. A price ceiling creates a shortage and changes how goods are rationed
If the market above (equilibrium price 30 won) is given a ceiling of 20 won, quantity demanded is and quantity supplied is : a shortage of 30. What price no longer rations is rationed instead by queues, lotteries, connections, black markets and lower quality.
The deadweight loss from quantity falling from 40 to 30 is the triangle between the demand and supply curves from 30 to 40 units. At a quantity of 30, consumers are willing to pay won and producers’ marginal cost is won.
With price held at 20, quantity supplied is 30 and quantity demanded 60, a shortage of 30. The triangle over the untraded range 30–40 is the deadweight loss of 75.
“Lower prices benefit consumers” holds only for the 30 people who actually buy. The losses of those who cannot buy and the cost of queuing must be subtracted to find the net effect on consumers as a whole. A price floor (a minimum wage, a guaranteed crop price) does the opposite and creates excess supply.
The claim that competitive equilibrium maximises total surplus holds only under perfect competition, no externalities and perfect information. Chapters 5–10 relax these assumptions one by one.
Check your understanding
Problem 1. A price ceiling of 20 is imposed in a market with demand and supply . Find the shortage and the deadweight loss.
Solution. Equilibrium solves : , . At 20, quantity demanded is 60 and quantity supplied 40, a shortage of 20. At a traded quantity of 40 the demand price is and the supply price , so the deadweight loss is .
Problem 2. In a rice market, the elasticities at equilibrium are and . A poor harvest shifts supply horizontally left by 7%. Roughly how much do price and quantity change?
Solution. A supply shock uses the same formula with the sign reversed. Price rises by . Quantity moves along the demand curve, so it falls by . Because demand is inelastic, most of the shock shows up in price, and farm revenue () actually rises by about 4.5%. That is why prices spike after a bad harvest.
References
- Hal Varian, Intermediate Microeconomics, ch. 1, 16
- N. Gregory Mankiw, Principles of Economics, ch. 4, 6
- MIT OpenCourseWare, 14.01 Principles of Microeconomics
Oiyo
Editorial DeskThe OIYO editorial desk researches money, law, lifestyle, and self-understanding topics against primary sources and public statistics. Every piece carries source notes and is reviewed on a regular cycle for accuracy and usefulness.