Economics•Chapter 4•10 min read•Updated September 28, 2026

Microeconomics — Consumer Theory: Utility Maximisation and Choice

O
OiyoContributor
4/11

Microeconomics — Consumers Equalise Marginal Utility per Won

If Introduction to Economics, Chapter 3 introduced the tangency condition, this chapter derives it, looks at the cases where it fails (corner solutions), and computes the two channels through which a price change alters demand (the substitution and income effects). Where the demand curve of Chapter 2 comes from is the conclusion of this chapter.

1. The budget constraint and indifference curves

A consumer with income MM facing prices PxP_x and PyP_y has the budget constraint Pxx+Pyy≤MP_x x + P_y y \le M. The slope of the budget line, −Px/Py-P_x/P_y, is the rate of exchange set by the market.

An indifference curve joins bundles that give the same utility. If preferences are monotone (more is better) and convex (mixtures are preferred to extremes), indifference curves slope downward, are convex to the origin and never cross. The absolute value of their slope is the marginal rate of substitution (MRS): how much yy the consumer is willing to give up for one more unit of xx.

Marginal rate of substitution
MRSxy=−dydx∣u=uˉ=MUxMUyMRS_{xy} = -\frac{dy}{dx}\Big|_{u=\bar u} = \frac{MU_x}{MU_y}
Along an indifference curve the change in utility is MU_x dx + MU_y dy = 0, so the slope is the ratio of marginal utilities.

2. Deriving the optimality condition

The Lagrangian for maximising utility u(x,y)u(x,y) subject to the budget constraint is L=u(x,y)+λ(M−Pxx−Pyy)\mathcal{L}=u(x,y)+\lambda(M-P_x x-P_y y). The first-order conditions are:

∂u∂x=λPx,∂u∂y=λPy\frac{\partial u}{\partial x}=\lambda P_x,\qquad \frac{\partial u}{\partial y}=\lambda P_y

Dividing one by the other gives the optimality condition.

Interior-solution condition
MRSxy=MUxMUy=PxPy⟺MUxPx=MUyPy=λMRS_{xy}=\frac{MU_x}{MU_y}=\frac{P_x}{P_y}\quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad \frac{MU_x}{P_x}=\frac{MU_y}{P_y}=\lambda
Marginal utility per won must be equal. If one is larger, moving spending towards that good raises utility. λ is the extra utility from one more won of income (the marginal utility of income).

With MUx=10MU_x=10, MUy=4MU_y=4, Px=2,000P_x=2{,}000 won and Py=1,000P_y=1{,}000 won, marginal utility per won is 1/2001/200 for xx and 1/2501/250 for yy. Taking 1,000 won away from yy and spending it on xx raises utility. Because marginal utility diminishes, the gap narrows as spending shifts, and the equality is restored.

3. Cobb–Douglas demand

If u=xay1−au=x^{a}y^{1-a}, the first-order condition gives a y(1−a) x=PxPy\frac{a\,y}{(1-a)\,x}=\frac{P_x}{P_y}; solving it together with the budget constraint yields the demand functions.

Cobb–Douglas demand functions
x∗=aMPx,y∗=(1−a)MPyx^*=\frac{aM}{P_x},\qquad y^*=\frac{(1-a)M}{P_y}
A fixed share of income (a, 1−a) is spent on each good. The own-price elasticity is −1, the income elasticity 1 and the cross elasticity 0.

With u=xyu=xy (a=1/2a=1/2), M=12M=12 won, Px=2P_x=2 won and Py=1P_y=1 won, x∗=3x^*=3, y∗=6y^*=6 and utility is 18. Here λ=MUx/Px=y/2=3\lambda=MU_x/P_x=y/2=3. If income rises to 13 won, x=3.25x=3.25 and y=6.5y=6.5, so utility becomes about 21.1 — an increase of about 3, consistent with λ\lambda being the marginal utility of one won of income. The general interpretation of the Lagrange multiplier is in Mathematics for Economists, Chapter 3.

4. Corner solutions: when the equality fails

Depending on preferences, the optimum can lie on an axis.

  • Perfect substitutes (u=x+yu=x+y): indifference curves are straight lines. If Px<PyP_x<P_y, the consumer buys only xx. There is no interior tangency where the MRS (= 1) equals the price ratio.
  • Perfect complements (u=min⁡(x,y)u=\min(x,y)): indifference curves are L-shaped. The consumer always chooses the kink where x=yx=y, a fixed ratio regardless of prices. The MRS is not defined there.

At a corner solution we can have MUx/Px>MUy/PyMU_x/P_x > MU_y/P_y with y=0y=0. The first-order conditions become inequalities (the Kuhn–Tucker conditions).

5. Two channels of a price change: the Slutsky decomposition

When the price of xx rises, two things happen at once: xx becomes relatively more expensive, so the consumer shifts towards yy (the substitution effect), and the same income buys less (the income effect).

In the example above, if PxP_x rises from 2 to 4 won, the new demand is x=12/(2×4)=1.5x=12/(2\times 4)=1.5. Let us split the total effect of −1.5-1.5. To let the consumer afford the original bundle (3, 6) at the new prices, income must be compensated to M′=4×3+6=18M'=4\times 3+6=18 won. With this compensated income, demand is x=18/8=2.25x=18/8=2.25.

  • Substitution effect: 3 → 2.25, −0.75
  • Income effect: 2.25 → 1.5, −0.75
Substitution and income effects of a price rise
x y 32.251.5 B₁ B₂ B′ u = 18 u = 9 A B C

A(3, 6)→B(2.25, 9) is the substitution effect and B→C(1.5, 6) the income effect. B₁ is the original budget, B₂ the budget after the price rise and the dashed B′ the compensated budget, which passes through the original bundle A at the new price ratio (with Slutsky compensation B lies on an indifference curve slightly above u = 18).

Slutsky equation
∂x∂Px=∂xs∂Px−x ∂x∂M\frac{\partial x}{\partial P_x} = \frac{\partial x^{s}}{\partial P_x} - x\,\frac{\partial x}{\partial M}
The first term (the slope of compensated demand) is never positive. The sign of the second term depends on the income elasticity. For a normal good both effects point the same way.
Effects of a rise in the price of x
GoodSubstitution effectIncome effectTotal effect
Normal goodx↓x↓x↓
Inferior good (not Giffen)x↓x↑ (small)x↓
Giffen goodx↓x↑ (large)x↑

There are two ways to compensate. Slutsky compensation lets the consumer afford the original bundle; Hicks compensation keeps the consumer on the original indifference curve. For small price changes the two coincide. When solving a problem, first check which compensation it uses.

The same decomposition applies to labour supply. A higher wage makes leisure more expensive, so people work more (substitution effect), but it also raises income, so people want more leisure (income effect). If the income effect dominates at high wages, the labour supply curve bends backwards. Public Finance, Chapter 4 applies this logic to income tax.

Even without knowing the utility function, we can test choice data for consistency. If bundle B was chosen when A was affordable, then A must not be chosen when B is affordable (the weak axiom of revealed preference, WARP). Data that violate it cannot be rationalised by stable preferences.

6. Duality: maximising utility and minimising expenditure are two faces of one problem

So far we solved “the most utility from a given income”. Turning it around — “the cheapest way to reach a given utility” — lands on the same tangency. The value functions of the two problems are the indirect utility function V(Px,Py,M)V(P_x,P_y,M) and the expenditure function e(Px,Py,u)e(P_x,P_y,u). For u=xyu=xy:

Value functions for u = xy
V=M24PxPy,e=2PxPy u,xh=Py uPxV=\frac{M^2}{4P_xP_y},\qquad e=2\sqrt{P_xP_y\,u},\qquad x^h=\sqrt{\frac{P_y\,u}{P_x}}
V plugs the optimal bundle into utility; e inverts V with respect to M. x^h is Hicksian (compensated) demand, holding utility fixed.

Differentiating the value functions returns the demands, with no need to re-solve the optimisation — that is what duality is for.

Roy's identity and Shephard's lemma
x∗=−∂V/∂Px∂V/∂M,xh=∂e∂Pxx^*=-\frac{\partial V/\partial P_x}{\partial V/\partial M},\qquad x^h=\frac{\partial e}{\partial P_x}
For u=xy, Roy's identity gives (M²/4P_x²P_y)/(M/2P_xP_y)=M/2P_x, the Marshallian demand; Shephard's lemma gives √(P_y u/P_x), the Hicksian demand.

In the example of section 5 (M=12M=12, Py=1P_y=1), when PxP_x rises from 2 to 4, Hicksian compensation puts the substitution effect at xh=18/4≈2.12x^h=\sqrt{18/4}\approx2.12, i.e. −0.88-0.88 — slightly larger than the Slutsky figure of −0.75-0.75. The gap vanishes as the price change gets smaller.

A. Measuring the cost of a price rise in money

There are three ways to put a money value on the consumer’s loss from a price rise.

Welfare cost of P_x rising from 2 to 4 (M=12, P_y=1)
MeasureDefinitionValue
Compensating variation CVExtra income needed at new prices to keep the original utility (18): e(4,1,18) − 12about 4.97
Equivalent variation EVIncome that would have to be taken away at old prices to bring utility down to the new level (9): 12 − e(2,1,9)about 3.51
Loss of consumer surplus ΔCSArea under Marshallian demand ∫₂⁴ 6/P dP = 6 ln 2about 4.16

For a normal good, EV≤ΔCS≤CVEV\le\Delta CS\le CV always holds (for a price rise). The gaps come from the income effect; the smaller it is, the closer the three measures. Cost-benefit analysis uses the area under Marshallian demand because the gap is usually small; for goods that take a large share of income, such as housing, computing CV or EV directly is more accurate.

Marshallian and Hicksian demand
x P_x 31.5 24 Marshallian Hicksian (u=18) A C B*

The two curves meet at A(3, 2). When the price rises to 4, Marshallian demand falls to C (1.5), but Hicksian demand, compensated to keep utility at 18, stops at B* (2.12). The difference is the income effect; for a normal good the Hicksian curve is steeper.

Check your understanding

Problem 1. With u=xyu=xy, M=24M=24, Px=3P_x=3 and Py=2P_y=2, find the optimal bundle and λ\lambda.

Solution. x∗=24/(2×3)=4x^*=24/(2\times3)=4 and y∗=24/(2×2)=6y^*=24/(2\times2)=6. λ=MUx/Px=y/3=2\lambda=MU_x/P_x=y/3=2, equal to MUy/Py=x/2=2MU_y/P_y=x/2=2: marginal utility per won is equalised across the two goods.

Problem 2. For the same consumer, PxP_x rises from 3 to 6. Find the compensating variation (CV), the equivalent variation (EV) and the loss of consumer surplus, and check their order.

Solution. Initial utility is V=242/(4×3×2)=24V=24^2/(4\times3\times2)=24 and final utility 242/(4×6×2)=1224^2/(4\times6\times2)=12. CV=e(6,2,24)−24=2288−24≈9.94CV=e(6,2,24)-24=2\sqrt{288}-24\approx9.94 and EV=24−e(3,2,12)=24−272≈7.03EV=24-e(3,2,12)=24-2\sqrt{72}\approx7.03. The loss of consumer surplus is ∫3612/P dP=12ln⁡2≈8.32\int_3^6 12/P\,dP=12\ln2\approx8.32. So EV<ΔCS<CVEV<\Delta CS<CV, the order expected for a normal good.

References

  • Hal Varian, Intermediate Microeconomics, ch. 2–8
  • Angus Deaton and John Muellbauer, Economics and Consumer Behavior, ch. 2
  • MIT OpenCourseWare, 14.01 Principles of Microeconomics
O

Oiyo

Editorial Desk

The OIYO editorial desk researches money, law, lifestyle, and self-understanding topics against primary sources and public statistics. Every piece carries source notes and is reviewed on a regular cycle for accuracy and usefulness.