
Managerial Accounting — Extending CVP Analysis: Sales Mix, After-Tax Target Profit and Uncertainty
The basic CVP analysis of Cost Accounting chapter 13 assumed one product, pre-tax profit and known demand. Real companies sell several products, pay tax and cannot be sure of their sales volume. This chapter relaxes these three assumptions one by one to fit CVP analysis to real decisions.
1. Multiple products and the sales mix
Company BN sells product A (price ₩100,000, variable cost ₩60,000) and product B (price ₩80,000, variable cost ₩60,000) in a unit ratio of 3 : 1. Common fixed costs are ₩14 million.
A. When the sales mix changes
If the mix shifts to 1 : 1, the weighted-average contribution margin becomes and break-even rises to about 467 units. Even at the same total volume, profit falls as the share of low-margin B grows. Tying sales incentives only to revenue can tilt the mix toward easy-to-sell, low-margin products.
About 467 units is the approximation to the continuous-volume threshold . If A and B must be sold in whole units while preserving an exact 1 : 1 mix, calculate in bundles of one A plus one B. Each bundle contributes KRW 60,000, so at least 234 bundles are needed: 234 A and 234 B, or 468 units. The contribution from 233 bundles is KRW 13.98 million, below fixed costs of KRW 14 million.
2. After-tax target profit
With income tax, a target after-tax profit is converted to pre-tax profit.
3. Sensitivity analysis
Look at how the result changes when assumptions change. Cutting A’s price by 10% (from KRW 100,000 to KRW 90,000) lowers A’s contribution margin to KRW 30,000 and the weighted average to in units of KRW 10,000. The continuous-volume break-even threshold is units, about 27.27% above the baseline of 400. If the 3 : 1 mix, unit variable costs and fixed costs remain unchanged, preserving pre-cut profit requires volume to be at least times its previous level, an increase of about 27.27%. A smaller increase reduces profit. This ratio does not apply unchanged if the price cut changes the mix or costs.
| Change | New weighted-average CM | New break-even point |
|---|---|---|
| A's price cut by 10% | ₩27,500 | About 509 units |
| Variable costs up 5% (both products) | ₩35,000 − ₩3,000 = ₩32,000 | About 438 units |
| Fixed costs up 10% | ₩35,000 | 440 units |
The table’s approximately 509 and 438 units are continuous-volume approximations. With an exact 3 : 1 mix in whole units, treat three A plus one B as a bundle and round the required bundle count up. After the price cut, contribution is KRW 110,000 per bundle, requiring 128 bundles (512 units). After the variable-cost increase, contribution is KRW 128,000 per bundle, requiring 110 bundles (440 units). One fewer bundle, 127 or 109 respectively, fails to cover fixed costs. With only fixed costs rising 10%, exactly 110 bundles, or 440 units, suffice. An approximate mix or continuous quantities requires its own quantity constraints.
4. Uncertainty and expected value
When volume is uncertain, compute expected profit from the probability of each scenario. BN is considering spending ₩3 million on a new advertising campaign. Without it, sales are 500 units with 50% probability and 700 with 50%. With it, 600 units with 50% and 900 with 50%.
- No advertising: expected volume 600 units, expected profit (₩7 million)
- Advertising: expected volume 750 units, expected profit (₩9.25 million)
The expected incremental profit from advertising is ₩2.25 million. In the worst scenario (600 units), however, profit is ₩4 million, only ₩500,000 more than the worst case without advertising (500 units, ₩3.5 million). A risk-averse manager looks not only at expected value but also at the variance of profit and the worst outcome.
Check your understanding
Company BO sells products P (contribution margin ratio 50%) and Q (30%) in a revenue ratio of 60 : 40. Fixed costs are ₩21 million and the tax rate is 25%. What are break-even sales and the sales needed for an after-tax profit of ₩9 million?
The weighted-average contribution margin ratio is . Break-even sales are (₩50 million). The pre-tax profit for ₩9 million after tax is (₩12 million), so required sales are , about ₩78.57 million.
References
- Charles Horngren, Srikant Datar and Madhav Rajan, Cost Accounting: A Managerial Emphasis, ch. 3
- Ray Garrison, Eric Noreen and Peter Brewer, Managerial Accounting, ch. 5
- Robert Kaplan and Anthony Atkinson, Advanced Management Accounting, ch. 2
Oiyo
Editorial DeskThe OIYO editorial desk researches money, law, lifestyle, and self-understanding topics against primary sources and public statistics. Every piece carries source notes and is reviewed on a regular cycle for accuracy and usefulness.