Cost Accounting — Allocating Support Department Costs: Direct, Step-Down and Reciprocal Methods
A factory has production departments that make products directly (machining, assembly) and support departments that serve them (power, maintenance, quality control). To calculate product costs, support department costs must first be moved to production departments and then applied to products with production department rates. This chapter compares three ways of doing the first step. The case for departmental rates was made in chapter 5.
1. Data
Company YY’s support departments are power (S1) and maintenance (S2); its production departments are machining (P1) and assembly (P2). Support department costs and the shares of services provided are as follows.
| Providing department | Cost (₩10,000) | To S1 | To S2 | To P1 | To P2 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Power (S1) | 200 | — | 20% | 50% | 30% |
| Maintenance (S2) | 300 | 10% | — | 60% | 30% |
2. Direct method
Services exchanged between support departments are ignored, and costs are allocated only to production departments in proportion to their shares.
- S1: P1 and P2 in the ratio 50 : 30 → P1 , P2 75
- S2: P1 and P2 in the ratio 60 : 30 → P1 , P2 100
P1 receives ₩3.25 million and P2 ₩1.75 million. It is the simplest calculation but ignores the reality that maintenance uses power.
3. Step-down method
Support departments are allocated in a set sequence: a department allocated earlier allocates to later ones and receives nothing back afterwards. Usually the department that provides the most service to other support departments goes first. S1 (20% to S2) is allocated before S2 (10% to S1).
- S1’s 200: 40 to S2, 100 to P1, 60 to P2
- S2’s : nothing goes back to S1, so P1 and P2 share 60 : 30 → P1 , P2 ≈ 113.3
P1 receives about ₩3.267 million and P2 about ₩1.733 million. Changing the sequence changes the result.
4. Reciprocal method
All services exchanged between support departments are reflected. Each support department’s total cost (its own cost plus costs received from other support departments) is found with simultaneous equations.
| Department | From S1 (234.69) | From S2 (346.94) | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| P1 | 50% → 117.35 | 60% → 208.16 | 325.51 |
| P2 | 30% → 70.41 | 30% → 104.08 | 174.49 |
| Total | 500.00 |
| Method | P1 | P2 |
|---|---|---|
| Direct method | 325.0 | 175.0 |
| Step-down method (S1 first) | 326.7 | 173.3 |
| Reciprocal method | 325.5 | 174.5 |
In this example the shares exchanged between support departments are small, so the differences are small, but with larger shares the direct method’s distortion grows. Under every method the production departments’ total is the same ₩5 million: allocation divides the total, it does not increase or reduce it.
5. Dual rates
Dual-rate allocation splits support department costs into variable and fixed costs and allocates them on different bases: variable costs on actual usage, fixed costs on maximum available usage (practical capacity). Fixed costs arise from providing enough capacity for the maximum that production departments need, so this stops other departments from bearing those costs in months when one department uses little.
Check your understanding
Company ZZ’s support department A (cost ₩1 million) provides 25% of its services to B, 50% to production department X and 25% to Y; support department B (cost ₩1.5 million) provides 20% to A, 40% to X and 40% to Y. How much is allocated to X and Y under the reciprocal method?
and . Substituting gives , so and . X receives and Y (₩10,000). The total of ₩2.5 million equals the two support departments’ combined costs.
References
- Charles Horngren, Srikant Datar and Madhav Rajan, Cost Accounting: A Managerial Emphasis, ch. 15
- Ray Garrison, Eric Noreen and Peter Brewer, Managerial Accounting, appendix on service department allocations
- Robert Kaplan and Anthony Atkinson, Advanced Management Accounting, ch. 3
Oiyo
Editorial DeskThe OIYO editorial desk researches money, law, lifestyle, and self-understanding topics against primary sources and public statistics. Every piece carries source notes and is reviewed on a regular cycle for accuracy and usefulness.