
Managerial Accounting — Short-Term Decisions: Special Orders, Make or Buy, Product Lines and Constrained Resources
This chapter applies the relevant cost principle of chapter 1 to four typical short-term decisions. In all four the question is the same: which revenues and costs change because of this decision? How fixed costs are treated — especially common fixed costs shared with other products — decides the answer.
1. Special orders
Company BK’s product sells for ₩50,000 per unit, variable cost is ₩30,000 and fixed costs are ₩20 million a year (₩2,000 per unit at a capacity of 10,000 units). A customer offers to buy 1,000 units at ₩35,000 each.
| Situation | Incremental revenue | Incremental cost | Opportunity cost | Incremental profit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Enough idle capacity (currently producing 8,000 units) | 3,500 | 3,000 | 0 | +500 → accept |
| Full capacity (all 10,000 units sold normally) | 3,500 | 3,000 | Contribution margin of 1,000 regular units: 2,000 | −1,500 → reject |
With idle capacity, fixed costs are irrelevant to the order. At capacity, full unit cost is ₩32,000, below the ₩35,000 offer. Acceptance nevertheless depends on incremental cost, not full cost: if there are no additional fixed costs or displaced regular sales, an order price above the ₩30,000 variable cost increases profit. At full capacity, the order displaces regular sales, so their contribution margin becomes an opportunity cost. Also consider qualitative factors such as the risk that existing customers learn of the discount and demand lower prices, and fair-trade issues.
2. Make or buy
BK makes 10,000 components itself. Per unit, costs are direct materials ₩10,000, direct labor ₩8,000, variable overhead ₩4,000 and fixed overhead ₩10,000 (of which a supervisor’s salary of ₩3,000 is avoidable if production stops). An outside supplier offers them at ₩23,000 each.
If the capacity freed by buying could be rented out for ₩3 million a year, that rent is also a benefit of buying (an opportunity cost of making). Conversely, the supplier’s quality and delivery risks and the risk of leaking key technology are weighed outside the numbers.
3. Dropping a product line
Company BL’s profit by product line is as follows. ₩6 million of common fixed costs was allocated in proportion to sales.
| Item | A | B | C | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sales | 2,000 | 1,500 | 1,000 | 4,500 |
| Variable costs | (1,200) | (900) | (700) | (2,800) |
| Contribution margin | 800 | 600 | 300 | 1,700 |
| Avoidable fixed costs | (200) | (150) | (200) | (550) |
| Product line (segment) margin | 600 | 450 | 100 | 1,150 |
| Allocated common fixed costs | (267) | (200) | (133) | (600) |
| Operating profit | 333 | 250 | −33 | 550 |
C appears to have an operating loss of ₩330,000, but dropping it eliminates only its ₩3 million contribution margin and ₩2 million of avoidable fixed costs, while its ₩1.33 million share of common fixed costs is reloaded onto A and B. Company profit falls to (₩4.5 million). The criterion is not operating profit after allocation but the segment margin (contribution margin − avoidable fixed costs). If C complements A and B by helping them sell, the loss from dropping it is even larger.
4. Product mix under a constrained resource
Machine time is limited to 1,000 hours a month. Product X earns a contribution margin of ₩40,000 per unit and needs 2 machine hours; product Y earns ₩30,000 per unit and needs 1 machine hour. Monthly demand is 400 units of X and 600 of Y.
Make Y up to demand, 600 units (600 hours), and use the remaining 400 hours for 200 units of X. Contribution margin is (₩26 million). Making 400 units of X first (800 hours) and then 200 units of Y yields only (₩22 million). With several constraints, use linear programming. Expanding the capacity of the constrained resource (the bottleneck) is the fastest way to raise total profit.
Check your understanding
Company BM makes a component for product Z at ₩15,000 per unit (direct materials 6,000, direct labor 4,000, variable overhead 2,000, allocated fixed overhead 3,000). Fixed overhead does not fall if component production stops. An outside supplier offers ₩13,000 per unit, and buying would free space to make another product earning ₩4 million a year in additional contribution margin. With annual requirements of 5,000 units, should BM buy?
The relevant cost of making is the variable cost of ₩12,000, ₩1,000 less than the ₩13,000 purchase price, so ignoring the space, making is ₩5 million a year better. Adding the ₩4 million of contribution margin gained by buying, buying is still ₩1 million worse. Making remains ₩1 million a year better.
References
- Charles Horngren, Srikant Datar and Madhav Rajan, Cost Accounting: A Managerial Emphasis, ch. 11
- Ray Garrison, Eric Noreen and Peter Brewer, Managerial Accounting, ch. 12
- Eliyahu Goldratt, The Goal (theory of constraints)
Oiyo
Editorial DeskThe OIYO editorial desk researches money, law, lifestyle, and self-understanding topics against primary sources and public statistics. Every piece carries source notes and is reviewed on a regular cycle for accuracy and usefulness.