
Intermediate Accounting — Equity: Share Issues, Capital Reductions, Treasury Shares, Dividends and Liability vs Equity
Equity is the residual interest in assets after deducting liabilities. So the first question in equity accounting is “is this financial instrument really equity?”, and the second is “which box of equity does a transaction with owners move?”. The first is answered by K-IFRS 1032 (IAS 32), the second by the Korean Commercial Act and local practice. The basics of equity components were covered in Principles of Accounting chapter 5 and chapter 10. Earnings per share is covered in chapter 17.
1. Distinguishing liabilities from equity
If a financial instrument contains any contractual obligation to deliver cash or another financial asset, that part is a financial liability, even if its legal form is a share.
| Terms | Classification | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Holder can demand redemption | Financial liability | The entity cannot avoid redemption |
| Must be redeemed on a fixed date | Financial liability | Mandatory redemption |
| Only the entity can choose to redeem and dividends are discretionary | Equity | No obligation to deliver |
| No redemption obligation, but cumulative dividends must be paid | Dividend component is a liability (compound instrument) | Obligation to pay dividends |
A contract settled in the entity’s own equity instruments is equity only if it exchanges a fixed number of shares for a fixed amount. A contract under which the number of shares varies uses the shares like currency and is a financial liability.
2. Share issues
A. Rights issues
Issuing 10,000 shares with a par value of ₩5,000 at ₩9,000 each, with issue costs of ₩3 million, gives share capital of ₩50 million and share premium of ₩90 million − ₩50 million − ₩3 million = ₩37 million. Issue costs are deducted from equity, not expensed. If shares are issued below par, the difference is recorded as a discount on share issue (capital adjustment) and first offset against share premium.
B. Bonus issues, stock dividends and share splits
| Transaction | Share capital | Capital surplus / retained earnings | Number of shares | Par value |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bonus issue (10%) | +₩5m | Capital surplus (or legal reserve) −₩5m | 11,000 | ₩5,000 |
| Stock dividend (10%) | +₩5m | Retained earnings −₩5m | 11,000 | ₩5,000 |
| Share split (1:2) | No change | No change | 20,000 | ₩2,500 |
In all three, total equity and shareholders’ percentage interests are unchanged. A bonus issue turns legal reserves into share capital, a stock dividend turns distributable profit into share capital, and a share split moves no box of equity at all.
3. Treasury shares (cost method)
Treasury shares are recorded at cost and deducted from equity. On disposal, the difference between proceeds and cost is dealt with inside equity.
| Transaction | Gain or loss | Treatment |
|---|---|---|
| Buy 1,000 shares at ₩10,000 | — | Treasury shares 1,000 |
| Sell 300 shares at ₩13,000 | Gain 90 | Gain on disposal of treasury shares (capital surplus) 90 |
| Sell 500 shares at ₩7,000 | Loss 150 | First offset against the gain of 90; the remaining 60 is a loss on disposal (capital adjustment) |
| Retire the remaining 200 shares | — | Share capital down 100 (par ₩5,000); difference of 100 is a loss on capital reduction |
A loss on disposal is first offset against existing gains on disposal of treasury shares; any remainder is held as a capital adjustment and later written off through appropriation of retained earnings. Gains and losses are settled only within equity because of the principle that no profit or loss is recognized on transactions with owners.
4. Capital reductions
- Paid capital reduction: shares are retired for consideration paid to shareholders. If less than par is paid, the difference is a gain on capital reduction (capital surplus); if more, a loss on capital reduction (capital adjustment).
- Deficit-covering capital reduction (without consideration): share capital is reduced without payment to eliminate an accumulated deficit. Consolidating 20,000 shares of ₩5,000 par (share capital ₩100 million) at five into one reduces share capital to ₩20 million, and the ₩80 million reduction covers the deficit. If the reduction exceeds the deficit, the excess is a gain on capital reduction.
5. Appropriation of retained earnings and covering deficits
Retained earnings are divided into the legal reserve, voluntary reserves and unappropriated retained earnings. A deficit is usually covered first by unappropriated retained earnings and voluntary reserves, and then by legal reserves. Before the 2011 amendment of the Commercial Act, the earned legal reserve had to be used before the capital reserve, but since the amendment there is no order between the two (Commercial Act, Article 460). If the capital and earned legal reserves together exceed 1.5 times share capital, the excess may be reduced by a shareholders’ resolution and used, for example, for dividends (Article 461-2).
Check your understanding
Company AA (par ₩5,000) bought 2,000 treasury shares at ₩8,000 each. It then sold 800 shares at ₩9,500 and 700 shares at ₩6,000, and retired the remaining 500. There was no opening balance of gains on disposal of treasury shares. How do the equity items change at each step, and by how much has total equity fallen overall?
The purchase deducts treasury shares of ₩16 million from equity. Selling 800 shares brings in ₩7.6 million of cash; the ₩1.2 million difference from their cost of ₩6.4 million is a gain on disposal. Selling 700 shares brings in ₩4.2 million against a cost of ₩5.6 million, a loss of ₩1.4 million; it is first offset against the gain of ₩1.2 million, and the remaining ₩200,000 is a loss on disposal. Retiring 500 shares eliminates share capital of ₩2.5 million and treasury shares of ₩4 million, with the ₩1.5 million difference recorded as a loss on capital reduction. Total equity changes only by the cash flows: (₩10,000), a fall of ₩4.2 million. The retirement does not change total equity.
References
- Korea Accounting Standards Board, K-IFRS 1032 Financial Instruments: Presentation
- Korean Commercial Act, Article 459 (capital reserve), Article 460 (use of legal reserves) and Article 461-2 (reduction of reserves) — National Law Information Center
- Donald Kieso, Jerry Weygandt and Terry Warfield, Intermediate Accounting: IFRS Edition, ch. 15
Oiyo
Editorial DeskThe OIYO editorial desk researches money, law, lifestyle, and self-understanding topics against primary sources and public statistics. Every piece carries source notes and is reviewed on a regular cycle for accuracy and usefulness.