Macroeconomics — The Investment Function: The User Cost of Capital
Macroeconomics — Before Being a Function of the Interest Rate, Investment Is a Comparison of Capital’s Return and Cost
The IS curve of Chapter 4 sloped downward because investment responds to the interest rate. This chapter looks at the microeconomic basis for that response. Firms compare what one more unit of capital earns with what it costs — the same logic as net present value (NPV) in corporate finance, applied to macroeconomic variables. Investment is smaller than consumption in GDP but far more volatile, and it explains much of the business cycle.
1. The user cost of capital
The cost to a firm of using a machine for a year is not the price of the machine itself but the interest the money could have earned elsewhere plus the value the machine loses through wear over the year.
A firm adds capital until the value of the marginal product of capital equals the user cost. Because the marginal product of capital diminishes, a lower user cost raises the target capital stock.
Suppose a firm’s return on capital (the value of the marginal product per unit of capital divided by the price of capital goods) is , and :
- : → → target capital
- : →
If the current capital stock is 18, investment is 2 at an interest rate of 5% and 6 at 3%. A 2-point rate cut tripled investment. Adding up across all firms this relationship — lower rates raise the target capital stock and hence investment — gives the investment function .
When the user cost falls from 10% to 8%, the target capital stock rises from 20 to 24. The gap from the current capital stock is investment.
Keynes expressed the same decision through the marginal efficiency of capital (MEC): the discount rate that makes the present value of a project’s expected returns equal to its cost. Firms invest if the MEC exceeds the market interest rate. The key is expectations. If entrepreneurs turn pessimistic, the MEC falls and investment collapses even if interest rates are unchanged. These swings in expectations, which Keynes called “animal spirits”, shift the IS curve.
2. The accelerator
The target capital stock is also proportional to output. If each unit of output needs units of capital, and net investment is . Investment responds to the change in output, not its level. In an industry with , a slowdown in output growth from 5% to 3% cuts net investment by 40% even though output is still growing. This is one reason investment is far more volatile than consumption.
3. Tobin’s q
Because q reflects the stock market’s view of expected returns, it carries the same information as the user-cost model while being observable. It is also a channel through which rising share prices lead investment.
4. When investment becomes insensitive to interest rates
| Reason | Mechanism | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Irreversibility and uncertainty | For investments that cannot be undone, the option to wait has value | Waiting when policy or demand uncertainty is high |
| Credit constraints | The cost of external finance rises far above the interest rate, or credit is cut off | Small firms during a financial crisis |
| Excess capacity | With low utilisation the MPK itself is low | Early in a recession |
| Worsening expectations | The MEC and q fall, shifting IS left | Business pessimism |
Residential and inventory investment follow the same logic: the house price relative to construction cost (the q of housing) and the user cost of holding inventories (interest plus storage) drive each.
Check your understanding
A machine costs 200 million won, the real interest rate is 4% and depreciation is 8%. What is the annual user cost? million = 24 million won. If the machine earns a net return of 20 million won a year, the firm does not invest. If the interest rate falls to 1%, the user cost becomes 18 million won and the firm invests.
References
- N. Gregory Mankiw, Macroeconomics, ch. 17
- Dale Jorgenson, “Capital Theory and Investment Behavior,” American Economic Review (1963)
- James Tobin, “A General Equilibrium Approach to Monetary Theory,” Journal of Money, Credit and Banking (1969)
- Avinash Dixit and Robert Pindyck, Investment under Uncertainty (1994)
Oiyo
Editorial DeskThe OIYO editorial desk researches money, law, lifestyle, and self-understanding topics against primary sources and public statistics. Every piece carries source notes and is reviewed on a regular cycle for accuracy and usefulness.