Macroeconomics — Solving IS-LM Simultaneously and Comparative Statics
Macroeconomics — Two Arrows Cannot Replace a Simultaneous Solution
Chapter 4 and Chapter 7 shifted curves to see signs and magnitudes. This chapter solves the same model as a system of equations and writes the equilibrium and comparative-static coefficients as general formulas. These formulas are needed to answer “how much” and to see where the numbers in policy simulations come from.
1. Writing the system of equations
Write IS and LM as follows.
is the response of spending to the interest rate (including the multiplier), the government spending multiplier, the income sensitivity of money demand and its interest sensitivity. Collecting the endogenous variables and on the left gives
Solving with Cramer’s rule gives
2. Checking against earlier numbers
The Chapter 4 economy has , , , , , and .
This matches the graphical solution of Chapter 4.
3. Comparative-static coefficients
Differentiating the equilibrium formulas with respect to the exogenous variables gives the policy effects.
| Coefficient | General formula | Value | Check against Chapter 4 |
|---|---|---|---|
| dY/dG | μγ/(μ+βλ) | 4 | G +10 → Y +40 |
| dr/dG | λγ/(μ+βλ) | 0.1 | G +10 → r +1 pt |
| dY/d(M/P) | β/(μ+βλ) | 0.4 | M/P +20 → Y +8 |
| dr/d(M/P) | −1/(μ+βλ) | −0.04 | M/P +20 → r −0.8 pt |
The in the first row is the same as in Chapter 7. The coefficient table shows how each parameter corresponds to the story.
| Parameter | Fiscal effect | Monetary effect | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|
| γ (multiplier) | Larger | — | The same spending creates more demand |
| β (interest sensitivity of spending) | Smaller | Larger | Interest-rate changes move spending a lot (more crowding out, stronger monetary channel) |
| λ (income sensitivity of money demand) | Smaller | Smaller | The interest rate rises more when output rises |
| μ (interest sensitivity of money demand) | Larger | Smaller | LM becomes flatter |
4. The interest-rate lower bound breaks the linear solution
If real balances are raised sharply to 220, the linear solution is and . But the nominal interest rate cannot fall far below zero. The actual equilibrium is , set by IS at a zero interest rate; at a zero rate and output of 410 the required real balances are , so any increase beyond 205 does not move output. Once the interest rate hits zero, LM becomes effectively flat and we enter the liquidity-trap region of Chapter 7.
The linear model predicts an interest rate of −0.6% and output of 416, but because of the lower bound the actual equilibrium stays at a zero rate and output of 410.
Check your understanding
If falls from 20 to 5 (LM becomes steeper), what happens to the fiscal and monetary multipliers? The denominator becomes . and . The fiscal effect falls from 4 to 2.5 and the monetary effect rises from 0.4 to 1 — the same result as the table in Chapter 7.
References
- John Hicks, “Mr. Keynes and the ‘Classics’,” Econometrica (1937)
- Alpha Chiang and Kevin Wainwright, Fundamental Methods of Mathematical Economics, ch. 5, 8
- N. Gregory Mankiw, Macroeconomics, ch. 12
Oiyo
Editorial DeskThe OIYO editorial desk researches money, law, lifestyle, and self-understanding topics against primary sources and public statistics. Every piece carries source notes and is reviewed on a regular cycle for accuracy and usefulness.