Macroeconomics — Applying IS-LM: Slopes and Schools of Thought
Macroeconomics — Which Policy Is Stronger Depends on the Slopes, Not the School
Chapter 4 shifted IS and LM to see the signs of policy effects. This chapter looks at the slopes that determine their size. The long-running debate between “fiscal policy is powerful” (Keynesians) and “only monetary policy moves output” (monetarists) was in effect an empirical debate about how sensitive money demand and investment are to the interest rate.
1. Writing the multipliers in terms of parameters
Write IS as and LM as . is the sensitivity of spending to the interest rate (including the multiplier), the government spending multiplier, the income sensitivity of money demand and its interest sensitivity. Substituting from LM into IS:
With the example of Chapter 4 (, , , ), the fiscal multiplier is and the real-balance multiplier . This matches Chapter 4, where 10 trillion won of G raised output by 40 trillion and 20 of real balances raised it by 8 trillion.
2. Three regions by the interest sensitivity of money demand
Changing only reverses the relative strength of the two policies.
| μ | Shape of LM | Fiscal multiplier dY/dG | Real-balance multiplier dY/d(M/P) |
|---|---|---|---|
| → ∞ | Horizontal (liquidity trap) | 5 (no crowding out) | 0 |
| 20 | Gently upward-sloping | 4 | 0.4 |
| 5 | Steeply upward-sloping | 2.5 | 1 |
| → 0 | Vertical (classical) | 0 (full crowding out) | 2 (= 1/λ) |
Government spending of 10 trillion won shifts IS right by 50. With a flat LM the interest rate does not rise and output rises by 50; with a vertical LM only the interest rate rises and output is unchanged.
Liquidity trap (): when interest rates are so low that people are willing to hold unlimited money instead of bonds, increasing the money supply cannot push rates lower. Monetary policy cannot move output, and fiscal policy causes no crowding out because rates do not rise. The Great Depression of the 1930s and the zero-interest-rate period after 2008 are often seen as close to this situation.
Classical region (): if money demand does not respond to the interest rate, ties output to real balances. A fiscal expansion only raises the interest rate and crowds out an equal amount of private spending (full crowding out). Monetary expansion becomes the only way to move output — the same structure as the quantity theory of money in Chapter 3.
The interest sensitivity of investment plays the same role. If , spending does not change when rates change, so there is no crowding out (fiscal policy is strong), and monetary policy cannot raise spending even if it lowers rates (monetary policy is powerless).
3. The policy mix
| Situation | Primary instrument | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Recession + rates at the floor | Fiscal expansion | The interest-rate channel of monetary policy is blocked |
| Recession + room to cut rates | Monetary easing (possibly with fiscal support) | Raises investment without crowding out |
| Overheating + fiscal deficit | Fiscal tightening + monetary easing | Keeps output while lowering rates to shift the composition towards investment |
| Supply shock (prices up, output down) | IS-LM alone is not enough | Prices move, so the AD-AS model of Chapter 8 is needed |
Combining fiscal tightening with monetary easing moves IS left and LM right, lowering interest rates while keeping output roughly unchanged. At the same output the share of private investment rises relative to government spending, which favours capital accumulation in the long run.
Check your understanding
With , , and , what are the output effects of 10 trillion won of government spending and of 20 of real balances? The denominator is . The fiscal effect is trillion won and the monetary effect trillion won. As falls from 20 to 10, the fiscal effect shrinks (40 → 33.3) and the monetary effect grows (8 → 13.3).
References
- N. Gregory Mankiw, Macroeconomics, ch. 12
- John Hicks, “Mr. Keynes and the ‘Classics’,” Econometrica (1937)
- Paul Krugman, “It’s Baaack: Japan’s Slump and the Return of the Liquidity Trap,” Brookings Papers on Economic Activity (1998)
- MIT OpenCourseWare, 14.02 Principles of Macroeconomics
Oiyo
Editorial DeskThe OIYO editorial desk researches money, law, lifestyle, and self-understanding topics against primary sources and public statistics. Every piece carries source notes and is reviewed on a regular cycle for accuracy and usefulness.